Skip to content
Pluct Net

Pluct Net

Experienced businnes masters

Primary Menu
  • Business Plan Template
  • Company Business
  • General Article
  • Business News
  • Crypto News
  • Business
  • About Us
    • Advertise Here
    • Privacy Policy
    • Contact Us
    • Sitemap
  • Home
  • How should a Marshall plan for Ukraine work? | Barry Eichengreen
  • Business Plan Template

How should a Marshall plan for Ukraine work? | Barry Eichengreen

By Rose Weir 1 year ago

[ad_1]

Talking up a Marshall plan for Ukraine is a popular sport nowadays. The game starts by tossing out a figure for the cost of reconstructing Ukraine from the ravages of the Russian invasion – $250bn (£203m) or $500bn or $1tn, depending on assumptions about how much is destroyed, the cost of caring for refugees, and so forth. The overall cost of the postwar Marshall plan is then compared with US GDP in 1948, when the program started. This typically leads to the conclusion that the cost of Ukrainian reconstruction relative to the size of the donor countries will be in the same ballpark as the Marshall plan.

These kinds of comparisons are not, in fact, the best use of Marshall plan history. It is impossible to put a number on the cost of reconstruction as long as there remains uncertainty about the duration of the war and how much territory will be controlled by Ukraine’s legitimate government. Just because the US was prepared to provide postwar Europe with nearly 5% of its 1948 GDP, spread over four years, tells us nothing about whether this is the right level of support for Ukraine.

Other aspects of this history are more relevant to Ukraine’s situation. It is revealing, for example, that Marshall plan disbursals began even while there was still some fighting in Europe. Although the Greek civil war continued through the summer of 1949, Greece received Marshall aid in 1948. In fact, Greece received $300m already in 1947 under the auspices of the American Mission for Aid to Greece, whose structure provided the template for the Marshall plan.

Similarly, aid to Ukraine can start now, though it should be used with discretion. Repairing bridges that are simply destroyed again by Russia would serve no purpose.

It is also important to recall that Marshall plan funds were more than 90% grants and just 10% loans. Today there are calls for the western powers to guarantee new Ukrainian government bonds. This would bring the government’s borrowing costs down to single digits and provide funds for reconstruction. But it would leave Ukraine even more heavily indebted, when it already faces the challenge of restructuring its legacy debt. Guarantees for additional Ukrainian borrowing would merely be a way for western governments to cheap out on reconstruction aid.

Moreover, the US created an independent agency to administer the Marshall plan. Freed from the bureaucracies of the US State and Treasury Departments, the Economic Cooperation Administration (ECA) could ramp up quickly. It was able to tap private-sector expertise, starting with its head, Paul Hoffman, the president of Studebaker. It avoided entanglements with the UN, where the Soviet Union’s membership would have caused problems.

Aid for Ukraine should similarly be administered by an autonomous agency accountable to donor governments. While it can consult and, ideally, coordinate with the International Monetary Fund and the World Bank, it should preserve its independence, given Russian membership in both organisations.

The Marshall plan’s architects recognised the need for ownership on the part of aid recipients, while proceeding on the basis of “trust but verify.” European governments submitted detailed plans for spending down US funds. These were the bases for painstaking negotiations with the ECA before moneys were disbursed. In countries like Greece, where there were concerns about corruption, the ECA had hundreds of agents embedded in the relevant ministries. Administrative reforms were a focus and precondition for Marshall plan aid.

Ukrainians will be understandably sensitive about foreign interference in their reconstruction. But foreign oversight is the price of foreign aid, particularly on the scale that Ukraine will require. The government in Kyiv can provide reassurance by enhancing the transparency of its spending, for example by expanding its online public procurement portal ProZorro.

The Marshall plan prioritised rebuilding export capacity. It recognised the invigorating effects of international competition and the political benefits of European integration. Ukraine almost certainly faces a long road to the nirvana of EU membership. But the journey can be expedited if western aid is structured to align Ukrainian institutions and policies with those of the EU.

Finally, the Marshall plan allowed Europe to leapfrog a generation technologically. Europe was decades behind the US in adopting the “high-speed throughput” manufacturing methods on which the golden age of postwar economic growth was based. Rather than simply reconstructing European industry along prewar lines, an effort was made to transfer state-of-the-art American manufacturing technology. European officials, plant managers and trade unionists traveled to the US as part of Marshall plan-funded productivity missions to learn about these techniques and returned with new knowledge, yielding tangible benefits for productivity growth.

Ukraine now similarly has an opportunity to leapfrog a generation of technologies – to green its energy system, modernise its transportation and communications infrastructure and update urban planning. These are first and foremost tasks for the Ukrainians. But the west can and should help.

Barry Eichengreen is professor of economics at the University of California, Berkeley, and a former senior policy adviser at the IMF.

© Project Syndicate

[ad_2]

Source link

Tags: Amazon Fba Business, Atlanta Business Chronicle'S, Boss Baby Back In Business, Business Administration Degree, Business Attire Women, Business Card Design, Business Cards Templates, Business Casual Dress, Business Casual Outfits, Business Checking Account, Business Credit Card, Business For Sale Near Me, Business Intelligence Platform, Business Lawyer Near Me, Business Loan Calculator, Business Name Ideas, Business Professional Women, Business Spectrum Login, California Business Entity Search, Capital One Spark Business, Carl Weber'S The Family Business, Charlotte Business Journal, Custom Business Cards, Delaware Business Search, Fl Sos Business Search, Florida Business Search, Harvard Business Publishing, Insurance For Small Business, Kelley School Of Business, Maryland Business Express, Maryland Business Search, Moo Business Cards, National Business Furniture, New York Business Search, Ohio Business Gateway, Onedrive For Business, Online Business Ideas, Paramore Misery Business, Risky Business Cast, Small Business Insurance, Spectrum Business Customer Service, Tom Cruise Risky Business, Us Small Business Administration, Verizon Wireless Business, Verizon Wireless Business Login, Virtual Business Address, What Is Business Administration, Women'S Business Casual, Yelp Business Login, Yelp For Business

Continue Reading

Previous Web 3.0 Marketing for Small Business
Next Production houses are tweaking their T&Cs to get rich
September 2023
M T W T F S S
 123
45678910
11121314151617
18192021222324
252627282930  
« Aug    

Archives

Categories

  • Business
  • Business News
  • Business Plan Template
  • Business Site
  • Company Business
  • Crypto News
  • General Article
  • Selling A Business

Recent Posts

  • Mechanical Bull Rodeo Style Safety Concept – Seat Sensor Shut Off Innovation
  • Increase Business Revenue With an Innovation Strategy
  • Market Driven Innovation
  • How to Get the Best Rate on Your Commercial Mortgage
  • Hire a Proper Search Engine Optimization Consultant for Your Website
Intellifluence Trusted Blogger

BL

Tags

5e Business Profit Ahron Levy Columbia Business School Att Business Login business Business Consultant Certification Austin Business Insurance Cover Coronavirus Business Letter With Logo Example Business Located Easy Location Business Platform Stocks Business Positions Seattle Business Regulation Legal Services Daystarr For Business Dimagi Business Development Toolkit Do Business Schools Accept Entreprenuers Enironmentall Friendly Business Ideas Eric Early Republican Business Owner Essec Business School Dean Essential Business To Remain Open Example Small Business Fall Winter Business Hours Template Fdot Woman Owned Business Certification First Business Women United States First Com Business Fixing A Damaged Reputation Business Florida Business Enforcement Free Small Business Communication Tool Law School Business Entity Outlines Medical Business Trends Economics Mix Business And Personal Money Mlm Nit Small Business Legally New Business Agency Sales Questions Patricia Saiki Women'S Business 1990 Safety Business Proposal S Corp Business Deductions Skype For Business Recording Capacity Small Business Forums .Net Small Business Insurancr Tech Monkey Business Ttu Business Cards Template Turbotax Business Nys Forms Uf Business School General Studies What Business Hours Macgaffin Bar Yelp Business .Json Yelp Tax Attorney Small Business Your Business Department

getlinko

pluct.net | Magazine 7 by AF themes.

WhatsApp us